Exemplary punishing

Authors

Keywords:

exemplary punishing; pragmatism; general prevention; manipulations; unjustice; historical examples; corruption; terrorism

Abstract

Exemplary punishing is not something that is characteristic for the history, that is so strange and unbelievable today. We could say that today in Serbia, and not only in Serbia, there are still many examples of exemplary punishing. One of the very typical examples is the verdict for those who were sentenced for the murder of French football fun Brice Taton. The author of this text thinks that exemplary punishing is not just full, neither effective, in spite ordinary people usually think that with a strong, severe punishment many positive social effects could be achieved. First of all with exemplary punishing you could punish some completely innocent person, only if you think that with that you could get some positive social effects. Than, when the word is about exemplary punishing one person usually is liable for all others. There are several persons that are guilty, but you can not get all of them, then you catch only one and he/she is liable for all of them. It is not justfull considers the author. In the case of exemplary punishing, the frequency of some kind of criminality has great impact on the penal policy, which is also unjustfull. The exemplary punishing usually is some kind of political message that is sent to voters. It is not necessary to say how unjustfull it is. The author of this article also cites some examples of exemplary punishing from history, from Jesus, through burning beaches at the stake in the middle age, up to nowadays punishing terrorists in Guantanamo bay and punishing corrupted politicians in China. In former Yugoslavia, some opponents of communist regime, were exemplary punished and sent to prison, but, it did not have any effect, because they were those became leaders in the civil war that broke Yugoslavia. In spite all of that, exemplary punishing is presented nowadays very much, especially when the word is about some special kinds of criminality that irritate publicity. Usually the word is about corruption, terrorism, drug offences and football fun hooligans.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Atanacković, D. 1976. Kriterijumi odmeravanja kazne. Beograd.

Backović, A. 1996. "Prilog psihoanalitičkom razumjevanju kazne." Paper presented at the Conference of the Serbian Association for Criminal Law and the Criminal Law Association of Montenegro, "Smrtna kazna – večita dilema," Herceg Novi.

Ćirić, J. 2001. Društveni uticaji na kaznenu politiku sudova. Beograd.

Ćirić, J. 2011. "Pravna nauka u Srbiji danas." Srpska politička misao 2. https://doi.org/10.22182/spm.3222011.12

Ćirić, J., Đ. Đorđević, and R. Sepi. 2006. Kaznena politika sudova u Srbiji. Beograd.

Dressler, J. 1995. Understanding Criminal Law. New York: Matthew Bender, Irwin Times Mirror Books.

Fatić, A. 1995. Kazna kao metafora. Beograd.

Fuko, M. 1997. Nadzirati i kažnjavati – Rođenje zatvora. Translated from French to Serbian. Sremski Karlovci.

Grasberger, R. 1958. Psihologija krivičnog postupka. Translated from German by D. Dimitrijević. Sarajevo.

Hogarth, J. 1971. Sentencing as a Human Process. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. https://doi.org/10.3138/9781487599553

Jovašević, D. 2008. "Krivična dela korupcije." Strani pravni život 3.

Lejins, P. P. 1978. "Kriminogeneza." Jugoslovenska revija za kriminologiju i krivično pravo 2–3.

Milutinović, M. 1984. Kriminalna politika. Beograd.

Musić, R. 1962. "Može li broj krivičnih dela na području jednog suda da utiče na visinu kazni." Pravni život 1.

Nojbaher, H. 2007. Srbi u memoarima Hermana Nojbahera. Beograd.

Primorac, I. 1978. Prestup i kazna. Beograd.

Stojanović, Z. 1994. "Generalna prevencija i zaštitna funkcija krivičnog prava." Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu – u čast akademika profesora Milana Milutinovića 1–2.

Vranjanac, D. 2010. "Norma kao zapovest." Strani pravni život 2.

Zlatarić, B., and Z. Šeparović. 1977. Krivično pravo – opšti deo. Zagreb.

Downloads

Published

27.04.2012

How to Cite

Ćirić, Jovan. 2012. “Exemplary Punishing”. Crimen 3 (1):21-38. https://epub.ius.bg.ac.rs/index.php/crimenjournal/article/view/554.

Issue

Section

Articles