THE MEANING OF “WAR OR OTHER PUBLIC EMERGENCY THREATENING THE LIFE OF THE NATION” IN THE JURISPRUDENCE OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
Abstract
The European Convention on Human Rights states that human rights can be derogated only during “war”, which has never been done, or “other public emergency threatening the life of the nation”, which was first defined a threat to the State’s community organised life affecting its whole population (Lawless case). In the Greek case the Court specified that the danger must be imminent and actual, have effects on the whole nation, threaten the continuance of the community’s life and be unmanageable by measures of ordinary law. The Court thereafter affirmed that a public emergency can last many years and that the crisis can be present only in part of a state’s territory. The State, however, has no “unlimited power of appreciation” due to the Court’s supervision. The author thinks that Covid-19 can be deemed a public emergency because the conditions from the Greek case are fulfilled.
References
Eboli, Valeria. 2010. La tutela dei diritti umani negli stati di emergenza. Milano: Giuffrè Editore.
Factsheet – Derogation in time of emergency, European Court of Human Rights. 2020. https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/fs_derogation_eng.pdf, last visited 22 October 2020.
Greer, Steven. 2000. The Margin of Appreciation: Interpretation and Discretion Under the European Convention on Human Rights (Human rights files No 17). Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing.
Gross, Oren. 1998. “Once More unto the Breach”: The Systemic Failure of Applying the European Convention on Human Rights to Entrenched Emergencies. Yale Journal of International Law 23: 437-501.
Guide on Article 15 of the European Convention on Human Rights, Derogation in time of emergency, Updated on 30 April 2021. 2021. https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/Guide_Art_15_ENG.pdf, last visited 10 November 2021.
Kirchner, Stefan. 2010. Human Rights guarantees during states of emergency: the European Convention on Human Rights. Baltic Journal of Law & Politics 3, 2: 1-25.
Kovačević, Nikola. 2020. Analiza mera odstupanja od ljudskih i manjinskih prava tokom vanrednog stanja u Republici Srbiji izazvanog epidemijom zarazne bolesti COVID-19. Belgrade: A11- Inicijativa za ekonomska i socijalna pitanja.
Krstić, Ivana. 2020. Reaction of the European Convention on Human Rights Contracting Parties to the COVID-19 Pandemic. Iustinianus Primus Law Review 11, Special issue: 1-13.
Mutua, Makau wa. 2000. The African Human Rights System: A Critical Evaluation, Prepared for United Nations Development Programme. Human Development Report 2000.
Note verbale from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of San Marino, Strasbourg, 14 April 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809e2770, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Serbia, Strasbourg, 7 April 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809e1d98, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Permanent Representation of Albania, Strasbourg, 1 April 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809e0fe5, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Permanent Representation of Armenia, Strasbourg, 20 March 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809cf885, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Permanent Representation of Estonia, Strasbourg, 20 March 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809cfa87, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Permanent Representation of Georgia, Strasbourg, 23 March 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809cff20, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Permanent Representation of Latvia, Strasbourg, 16 April 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809e2bd8, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Permanent Representation of Romania, Strasbourg, 18 March 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809cee30, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Permanent Representation of the Republic of Moldova, Strasbourg, 20 March 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809cf9a2, last visited 27 December 2021.
Note verbale from the Permanent Representation of the Republic of North Macedonia, Strasbourg, 2 April 2020. 2020. https://rm.coe.int/09000016809e1288, last visited 27 December 2021.
Paulus, Andreas, Mindia Vashakmadze. 2009. Asymmetrical war and the notion of armed conflict – a tentative conceptualization. International review of Red Cross 91, 873: 95-125.
Paunović, Milan, Boris Krivokapić, Ivana Krstić. 2020. Međunarodna ljudska prava. Belgrade: Univerzitet u Beogradu – Pravni fakultet.
Petrović, Vesna, Dušan Pokuševski. 2020. Ljudska prava u Srbiji (januar-jun 2020. godine) - Poseban osvrt na poštovanje ljudskih prava u vreme vanrednog stanja. Belgrade: Beogradski centar za ljudska prava.
Pictet, Jean. 1952. Commentary on the I Geneva Convention. Geneva: International Committee of the Red Cross.
Schreuer, Christoph. 1982. Derogation of Human Rights in Situations of Public Emergency: The Experience of the European Convention on Human Rights. Yale Journal of International Law 9: 113-132.
Shaw, Malcolm N. 2008. International Law. Cambridge: Camridge University Press.
Svensson-McCarthy, Anna-Lena. 1998. The International Law of Human Rights and States of Exception: With Special Reference to the Travaux Preparatoires and the Case-law of the International Monitoring Organs. The Hague: Kluwer Law International.
Tanca, Antonio. 1990. Human Rights, Terrorism and Police Custody: The Brogan Case. European Journal of International Law 1, 1: 269-277.
The Lawless Case. 1962. Duke Law Journal 2: 249-258.
Zagato, Lauso. 2006. L’eccezione per motivi di emergenza nel diritto internazionale dei diritti umani. DEP. Deportate, esuli, profughe 5-6: 137-156.
Zeidy, Mohamed M. El. 2003. The ECHR and States of Emergency: Article 15-A Domestic Power of Derogation from Human Rights Obligations. San Diego International Law Journal 4, 1: 277-318.
