THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE AT THE CROSSROAD BETWEEN LAW AND POLITICS THE EXAMPLE OF THE CASELAW ON NUCLEAR WEAPONS
Abstract
The International Court of Justice is identified by Article 92 of the United Nations Charter as the “principal judicial organ of the United Nations”. This definition has consecrated the International Court of Justice as the World Court, as the guardian of the application of international law. Is this picture still actual? Is the International Court of Justice currently performing a guardian role? What does it happen when highly politically sensitive issues, like nuclear proliferation and nuclear disarmament, arrive before this Court? To address these questions, this work will analyse the case-law of the International Court of Justice on nuclear weapons. Retracing the jurisprudence of this Court on this issue will shade a light on many characteristics of the World Court and its members, questioning its concrete role in the present international arena.
References
Berman, Franklin. 2013. The International Court of Justice as an “agent” of Legal Development. 7-21 in The Development of International Law by the International Court of Justice edited by Christian Tams and James Sloan. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bianchi, Andrea. 2004. Dismantling the Wall: The ICJ’s Advisory Opinion and its Likely Impact on International Law. German Yearbook of International Law 47: 343- 391.
Bianchi, Andrea. 2013. Gazing at the Crystal Ball (again): State Immunity and Jus Cogens beyond Germany v Italy, Journal of International Dispute Settlement, 4: 457-475.
Bianchi, Andrea. 2016. International Law Theories: an inquiry into different ways of thinking. Oxford: Oxford University Press 5. Bianchi, Andrea. 2017. Choice and (the awareness of it) its consequences: the ICJ’s “structural bias” strikes again in the Marshall Islands case. American Journal of International Law 111: 81 -87.
Bonafè, Beatrice. 2017. Establishing the existence of a dispute before the International Court of Justice: Drawbacks and implications, Questions of International Law 45: 3-32.
Burton, Jhon. 1968. Systems, States, Diplomacy and Rules. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 8. Cassese, Antonio. 2012. The International Court of Justice. It is high time to restyle the respected old lady. 239-249 in Realizing Utopia: The Future of International Law, edited by Antonio Cassese. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Carreau, Dominique, Fabrizio Marella. 2018. Diritto Internazionale. Milano: Giuffrè editore. 10. Galindo, George. 2017. On Form, Substance, and Equality Between States. American Journal of International Law 111: 75-80.
Crawford, James, Joe McIntyre. 2012. The Independence and Impartiality of the ‘International Judiciary”. 187-214 in The Culture of Judicial Independence: Conceptual Foundations and Practical Challenges edited by Shimon Shetreet and Christopher Forsyth. Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff.
Couvreur, Philippe. 1996. The effectiveness of the International Court of Justice in the Peaceful Settlement of International Disputes. 83-116., in The International Court of Justice: Its Future Role After Fifty Years edited by Sam Muller, David Raič, Thuránszky. The Hauge, London, Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Einstein, Albert. Letter to Freud, 1932 available at https://en.unesco.org/ courier/mai-1985/why-war-letter-albert-einstein-sigmund-freud (last visited 19 February, 2021)
Forlati, Serena. 2014. The International Court of Justice. An Arbitral Tribunal or a Judicial Body. New York: Springer Publishing.
Gordon, Edward. 1987. Observations on the Independence and the Impartiality of the Members of the International Court of Justice. Connecticut Journal of International Law 2: 397-426.
Higgins, Rosalyn. 2009. Themes and Theories: Selected Essay, Speeches, and Writings in International Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Jaspers, Karl. 1960. La bomba atomica e il destino dell’uomo. Milano: Il Saggiatore.
Jennings, Robert.1998. The Role of the International Court of Justice. The British Year Book of International Law 68:1-40.
Keith, Kenneth James. 2017. Challenges to the Independence of the International Judiciary: reflections on the International Court of Justice. Leiden Journal of International Law 30: 137-154.
Kohen, Marcelo. 1999. The notion of “state survival. 293-314 in International Law, the International Court of Justice and Nuclear Weapons edited by Laurence Boisson de Chazournes and Philippe Sands. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Koskenniemi, Martti. 2011. The politics of International Law. Oxford and Portland: Hart Publishing.
Krisch, Nico. 2016. Capitulation in The Hague: The Marshall Island Cases. EJIL :TALK !
Lauterpacht, Hersh. 2011. The Function of Law in the International Community. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Obregó n, Liliana. 2017. The Third World judges: neutrality, bias or activism at the Permanent Court of International Justice and International Court of Justice? 181-200 in Research Handbook on International Courts and Tribunals edited by William Schabas and Sean Murphy. Cheltenham and Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Oellers-Frahm, Karin. 2017. The awareness requirement and its problematic consequences for the Court’s jurisdiction. Questions of International Law 45: 33-41.
Posner, Eric, Miguel Figuerido. 2005. Is the International Court of Justice Biased? The Journal of Legal Studies 34: 599-630.
Proulx, Vincent. 2017. The Marshall Islands Judgments and Multilateral Disputes at the World Court: Whither Access to International Justice? American Journal of International Law Unbound 111: 96-101.
Sands, Philippe. 2016. Reflection on International Judicialization. European Journal of International Law 27: 885-900.
Simma, Bruno. 2009. Universality of International Law from the Perspective of a Practitioner. European Journal of International Law 20: 265-297.
Scobbie, Ian. 2012. “All right, Mr. DeMille, I’ m ready for my close-up”: some critical reflections on Professor Cassese’s “The International Court of Justice: it is high time to restyle the respected old lady”. The European Journal of International Law 23:1071-1088.
Schwebel, Sthephen. 1986. Reflections on the Role of the International Court of Justice. Washington Law Review 61:1061-1071.
Schwebel, Sthephen. 2011. Justice in International Law- Selected writings of Sthephen M.Schwebl. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Terris, Daniel, Cesare, Romano, Leight Swigart. 2007. The International Judge: An Introduction to the Men and Women Who Decide the World’s Cases. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Zimmermann, Dominik. 2014. The Independence of International Courts – The adherence of the International Judiciary to a fundamental value of the administration of Justice. Oxford and Portland: Hart Publishing.
