Balancing opportunity: Between the presumption of innocence and res judicata
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5937/crimen2302153NKeywords:
svetlananenadic11@gmail.com, ivana.miljus@ius.bg.ac.rsAbstract
The criminal-political justification of the principle of opportunity is undoubtedly of significant importance for criminal justice, with multiple and diverse objectives and functions. Despite the fact that the application of this criminal procedural mechanism in public prosecution practice has been ongoing for over two decades, research results indicate that essential questions regarding its legal and procedural nature remain veiled in dilemmas even today - whether the suspect subject to its application should be considered innocent, and whether the decision to dismiss a criminal complaint based on the principle of opportunity can be equated with the res judicata. The paper presents specific research results regarding the interpretation of the effects of applying the principle of opportunity in criminal proceedings and the legal effects of decisions to dismiss criminal complaints based on the principle of opportunity in civil proceedings for compensation of damages arising from a "criminal act." By analyzing the concepts expressed in criminal legal science and utilizing the comparative legal method to a certain relevant extent, the authors aim to, starting from the procedural guarantee of the presumption of innocence, highlight the risks of equating the decision to dismiss a criminal complaint based on the application of the principle of opportunity with a final judgment. The primary de lege ferenda proposal is to establish a prohibition on criminal prosecution for the same criminal offense in cases of applying the principle of opportunity.
Downloads
References
Ashworth, A. 2006. "Four Threats to the Presumption of Innocence." The International Journal of Evidence and Proof 10 (4). https://doi.org/10.1350/ijep.10.4.241
Bejatović, S. 2013. "Pojednostavljene forme postupanja kao bitno obeležje reformi krivičnog procesnog zakonodavstva zemalja regiona." In Pojednostavljene forme postupanja u krivičnim stvarima – regionalna krivičnoprocesna zakonodavstva i iskustva u primeni, edited by Jovanović I. and Stanisavljević M. Beograd.
Bejatović, S., Kiurski, J., and Ilić, G. 2022. Priručnik za primenu načela oportuniteta krivičnog gonjenja, 2nd ed. Misija OEBS-a u Srbiji, Beograd.
Bugarski, T. 2017. "Pretpostavka nevinosti (obim i dejstvo u krivičnom postupku)." In Reformski procesi i poglavlje 23 (godinu dana posle) – krivičnopravni aspekt, edited by Bejatović S. Zlatibor.
Campbell, L. 2013. "Criminal Labels, the European Convention on Human Rights and the Presumption of Innocence." Modern Law Review 76 (4). https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2230.12030
Cigler, S. 1995. "Pojam načela legaliteta i oportuniteta krivičnog gonjenja." Arhiv za pravne i društvene nauke, no. 4. https://doi.org/10.5937/gakv9404003C
Danić, R. 1988. "Načelo legaliteta i oportuniteta krivičnog gonjenja." Master's thesis, Univerzitet u Beogradu – Pravni fakultet, Beograd.
Đokić, I., and Čvorović, D. 2021. "Krivičnoprocesne forme za rešavanje problema sitnog kriminaliteta u srpskom i nemačkom pravu." Revija za kriminologiju i krivično pravo, no. 2.
Đurđić. 2011. "Načelo oportuniteta krivičnog gonjenja u krivičnom postupku Srbije." Revija za kriminologiju i krivično pravo, no. 2–3.
Gless, S., and Zurkinden, N. 2017. "Negotiated Justice — Balancing Efficiency and Procedural Safeguards." In Challenges in the Field of Economic and Financial Crime in Europe and the US, edited by K. Ligeti and V. Franssen. Oxford – London – Portland.
Karlsruher Kommentar. 2023. Strafprozessordnung mit GVG, EGGVG und EMRK, 9th ed. C.H. Beck, München.
Kiurski, J. 2015. "Načelo oportuniteta krivičnog gonjenja." Doctoral dissertation, Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu, Beograd.
Kluth, C. 2016. "Die 'Schwere der Schuld' in § 153a StPO – zugleich ein Vorschlag zur Parallelisierung mit § 59 StGB de lege ferenda." Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster, Wissenschaftliche Schriften der WWU Münster, Münster.
Knežević, S. 2007. Zaštita ljudskih prava okrivljenog u krivičnom postupku. Centar za publikacije Pravnog fakulteta u Nišu, Niš.
Laudan, L. 2005. "The Presumption of Innocence: Material or Probatory?" Legal Theory 11 (4). https://doi.org/10.1017/S1352325205050184
Lazin, Đ. 2008. "The Principle of Opportunity of Criminal Prosecution and the International Legal Standards." In Stanje kriminaliteta u Srbiji i pravna sredstva reagovanja II deo, edited by Ignjatović Đ. Beograd.
Lippke, R. L. 2016. Taming the Presumption of Innocence. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190469191.001.0001
Meyer–Goßner, L., B. Schmitt, and M. Köhler. 2018. Strafprozessordnung, Gerichtsverfassungs-gesetz, Nebengesetze und ergänzende Bestimmungen, § 153a, 61st ed. C.H. Beck, München.
Miljuš, I. 2023. "Primena načela oportuniteta krivičnog gonjenja za krivična dela u vezi sa zloupotrebom opojnih droga." In Narko kriminalitet – prevencija i represija, edited by Bejatović S. and Čvorović D. Višegrad.
Nenadić, S. 2021. "Pretpostavka nevinosti – Sa posebnim osvrtom na praksu Evropskog suda za ljudska prava." Službeni glasnik, Beograd.
Roxin, C., and Schünemann, B. 2012. Strafverfahrensrecht, 26th ed. C. H. Beck, München.
Škulić, M. 2007. Komentar Zakonika o krivičnom postupku. Službeni glasnik, Beograd.
Škulić, M. 2013. "Odnos načela istine i pojednostavljenih formi krivičnog postupka." In Pojednostavljene forme postupanja u krivičnim stvarima regionalna krivičnoprocesna zakonodavstva i iskustva u primeni, edited by Jovanović I. and Stanisavljević M. Misija OEBS-a u Srbiji, Beograd.
Škulić, M. 2020. Krivično procesno pravo, 12th ed. Univerzitet u Beogradu – Pravni fakultet, Beograd.
Škulić, M. 2022. "Načelo ne bis in idem u kaznenom zakonodavstvu Republike Srbije." In Načelo ne bis in idem i pravna sigurnost građana (međunarodni pravni standardi, regionalna zakonodavstva i iskustva u primeni), edited by Bejatović S. and Novaković N. Beograd.
Thaman, S. C. 2007. "Plea-Bargaining, Negotiating Confessions and Consensual Resolution of Criminal Cases." In General Reports of the XVIITH Congress of the International Academy of Comparative Law, edited by K. Boele-Woelki and Sjef van Erp. Saint Louis University School of Law, Saint Louis.
Vučković, B. 2006. "Načelo legaliteta i načelo oportuniteta." In Nova rešenja u krivičnom zakonodavstvu i dosadašnja iskustva u njihovoj primeni, edited by S. Bejatović. XLIII Savetovanje Udruženja za krivično pravo i kriminologiju Srbije i Crne Gore, Zlatibor – Beograd.
Vultejus, U. 1999. "Legalitäts- und Opportunitätsprinzip." Zeitschrift für Rechtspolitik 32 (4).
Weigend, T. 2021. "Exclusion without Trial? Exclusion of Evidence and Abbreviated Procedures." Revista Brasileira de Direito Processual Penal 7 (1). https://doi.org/10.22197/rbdpp.v7i1.502
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Svetlana Nenadić, Ivana Miljuš
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The authors retain copyright and grant the journal the right of first publication, allowing others to share the work with proper attribution to the authors and acknowledgment of its original publication in this journal.
